1
MTC OOC / Re: ...Izee's Thread
« Last post by Izee on November 30, 2024, 07:30:18 PM »...When I wimped out in a Jury Trial...
I had a very amusing case that I just couldn't handle...so I handled it in a very professional manner...
...I RE-ASSIGNED IT to my new Associate Attorney...
It wasn't a very large case, and liability was clear against my client, so it was just about keeping the damages as low as possible. Problem was the PLAINTIFF'S ATTORNEY!!!!
Ever encounter someone who just rubbed you the wrong way when you first met them? And then he kept doing so, no matter what you did?
The Attorney was a 'bottom feeder', he had a small practice and mostly handled low level criminal Cases assigned to him by the County because the Defendant couldn't afford to hire a real attorney. I handled high level personal injury and business and tax cases, , so I was out of his League. He was Hispanic...I am half Hispanic, my Mother's maiden name was Rodriguez, and we just didn't mix. He was FULL of himself, and he was a short, ugly little man with a Zapata mustache. During discovery, he kept subtly needling me in ways that I had never encountered before. I actually lost my temper during a deposition...first and ONLY time that ever happened...and I YELLED at him...ON THE RECORD!!!...and stomped out. We had a Court Ordered Arbitration, and I ALMOST lost my temper again. I won the Arbitration...he rejected it...so the case was ordered to a Jury Trial.
I STEWED in my Office trying to figure out how I was going to handle myself...you get THAT angry in front of a Jury...and you LOSE the case...unless they are also angry at the other side. I FINALLY figured out what to do...I called in my newest attorney and said, "Hey, Trevor, you are going to have your first Jury Trial!" He asked, "When?"...I responded, "In two weeks!" He almost shit himself...
But, I worked closely with him every day, and helped him compose his Opening Statement, and assured him that since I was also the Attorney of Record, that I would sit in the Courtroom and watch and counsel him. I also told him that if it was going sideways that I would step in and take it over...
So, we arrived at the Courthouse, and I helped him set up at the Table, and then stepped back across the bar and sat in the gallery...I was the ONLY person watching the trial. The trial got going, and I consulted with Trevor and helped him select the Jury. I tried to do as little as possible when the Jury was present...they might think that Trevor didn't know what he was doing. Anyway, things were OK until the Opening Statements...
The Plaintiff Attorney went first, and gave the most BIZARRE opening statement that I have EVER HEARD!!!! He was waxing eloquent on how his client used to sit in the backyard under a tree, and play his guitar while his wife lovingly watched and listened from the kitchen window, and both were devastated that he couldn't do it anymore. I just sat, and looked bored...but Trevor was fidgeting...he was wondering if he should object. I had an eye on the Jury, and they were getting pissed...it was a little fender bender auto accident...and the Plaintiff was a Construction Worker who looked very healthy.
The other Attorney then made the most OUTRAGEOUS statement, and Trevor panicked!!!! He actually turned in his chair and looked back at me for a sign of what to do. I did my best to look calm and just shrugged...when my instincts were to stand up and give the Baseball "STAY" hand gestures that 3rd base coaches give to keep a runner on second! He turned back around, and I could see a number of Jurors grinning...they saw where the Queen Bitch was sitting! I just stayed quiet.
Trevor won the case, big time, and I only had to counsel him a few times on what to do.
I had a very amusing case that I just couldn't handle...so I handled it in a very professional manner...
...I RE-ASSIGNED IT to my new Associate Attorney...
It wasn't a very large case, and liability was clear against my client, so it was just about keeping the damages as low as possible. Problem was the PLAINTIFF'S ATTORNEY!!!!
Ever encounter someone who just rubbed you the wrong way when you first met them? And then he kept doing so, no matter what you did?
The Attorney was a 'bottom feeder', he had a small practice and mostly handled low level criminal Cases assigned to him by the County because the Defendant couldn't afford to hire a real attorney. I handled high level personal injury and business and tax cases, , so I was out of his League. He was Hispanic...I am half Hispanic, my Mother's maiden name was Rodriguez, and we just didn't mix. He was FULL of himself, and he was a short, ugly little man with a Zapata mustache. During discovery, he kept subtly needling me in ways that I had never encountered before. I actually lost my temper during a deposition...first and ONLY time that ever happened...and I YELLED at him...ON THE RECORD!!!...and stomped out. We had a Court Ordered Arbitration, and I ALMOST lost my temper again. I won the Arbitration...he rejected it...so the case was ordered to a Jury Trial.
I STEWED in my Office trying to figure out how I was going to handle myself...you get THAT angry in front of a Jury...and you LOSE the case...unless they are also angry at the other side. I FINALLY figured out what to do...I called in my newest attorney and said, "Hey, Trevor, you are going to have your first Jury Trial!" He asked, "When?"...I responded, "In two weeks!" He almost shit himself...
But, I worked closely with him every day, and helped him compose his Opening Statement, and assured him that since I was also the Attorney of Record, that I would sit in the Courtroom and watch and counsel him. I also told him that if it was going sideways that I would step in and take it over...
So, we arrived at the Courthouse, and I helped him set up at the Table, and then stepped back across the bar and sat in the gallery...I was the ONLY person watching the trial. The trial got going, and I consulted with Trevor and helped him select the Jury. I tried to do as little as possible when the Jury was present...they might think that Trevor didn't know what he was doing. Anyway, things were OK until the Opening Statements...
The Plaintiff Attorney went first, and gave the most BIZARRE opening statement that I have EVER HEARD!!!! He was waxing eloquent on how his client used to sit in the backyard under a tree, and play his guitar while his wife lovingly watched and listened from the kitchen window, and both were devastated that he couldn't do it anymore. I just sat, and looked bored...but Trevor was fidgeting...he was wondering if he should object. I had an eye on the Jury, and they were getting pissed...it was a little fender bender auto accident...and the Plaintiff was a Construction Worker who looked very healthy.
The other Attorney then made the most OUTRAGEOUS statement, and Trevor panicked!!!! He actually turned in his chair and looked back at me for a sign of what to do. I did my best to look calm and just shrugged...when my instincts were to stand up and give the Baseball "STAY" hand gestures that 3rd base coaches give to keep a runner on second! He turned back around, and I could see a number of Jurors grinning...they saw where the Queen Bitch was sitting! I just stayed quiet.
Trevor won the case, big time, and I only had to counsel him a few times on what to do.