...When I argued WITH THE COMPOSER!!!
...I had been asked to sit as Principal Cello in the local UC Campus, and did very well.
I helped with the students, and volunteered my time to sit in small ensembles, and raised money for the Music Dept.
One year, we played this Symphony, and I DIDN'T LIKE the 2nd Movement!!!
It is slow, and the cellos and basses play very short notes...using the bow! That is hard...your hand and arm gets very tasked...and making EACH NOTE sound the same is hard! I was sitting at the stand, glaring at the music when we took a break, and the Conductor came over to me, and asked..."Something wrong?" I looked up at him, and said, "This whole movement should have the cellos plucking the strings...each note would sound the same...and it would be easier to play." He nodded, and raised his baton, and said..."OK, start the piece, using your bow, as written." I played about 12 measures, and he stopped me, and said..."OK, let's try it your way, put down the bow." I did, and he started me again, and I plucked the strings. He stopped me, and asked..."Do you hear the difference?" I nodded...and he said..."Mendelssohn knew what he was doing", and walked away. I set down my cello, and went to take a break...Mendelssohn was RIGHT!!! Here is the movement...
...
https://youtu.be/6BiK2qBJL_0…The Conductor was also a Composer, and once, we put on a Concert with several of his works. They ranged from lyrical, to very modern Atonal works...that I DIDN'T LIKE...I just like melodic works...although I do love Shostokovich.
I was sitting, playing my cello in an Octet he had written, and was struggling with a passage. Technically, it was difficult...and the bowings and note shapings he had marked just didn't make sense to me. I actually wrote in my own idea of how tp play the passage, and did so at a rehearsal.
He stopped us all, and looked at me, and said..."Play that again." I did so, using my markings, and he frowned, and said..."No, no, no...do it as I have marked it." I started arguing with him, saying that my phrasing sounded better...and the violist tapped me on the shoulder with her bow, and said..."Ah, last I looked at the cover page, HE WROTE THIS...NOT YOU!!!"
…I nodded, and erased my markings, and the Conductor had me play it the way he had written it...and nodded and said..."Practice it that way"...and I did.
…Another one of my "Finer Moments"....